HostGator vs Hostinger: which costs less over time?
Both sell cheap shared hosting with steep renewals. The difference is how long you prepay and what's included.
Hostinger is cheaper up front if you prepay 4 years ($2.99/mo on Premium), and both entry plans renew at about $10.99/mo. HostGator gives you 10 sites and cPanel on its entry plan against Hostinger's 3, and a shorter commitment. Hostinger includes more (weekly backups, a cheaper domain renewal). For most single-site owners, Hostinger is the better value; for several small sites on cPanel, HostGator still makes sense.
We earn a commission from Bluehost, HostGator, Namecheap and Cloudways links on this page. We have no affiliate relationship with Hostinger, SiteGround or GoDaddy. It never affects our rankings. See our Advertiser disclosure.
Prices side by side
What's included
Cost over the long run
Over four years, Hostinger Premium costs about $144 (all at the intro rate) against roughly $135 for three years of HostGator plus a year at the 1-year renewal ($158), about $293. Over six years the gap narrows because both renew near $10.99, but Hostinger's cheaper domain renewal and included backups still save you money each year.
Performance and support
Published speed tests and reviewers tend to rate Hostinger faster on shared plans, and CNET rated HostGator 7/10, "only acceptable for casual users". HostGator's strengths are cPanel, more sites per plan, and phone support. Hostinger supports customers by chat and email only.
- 10 sites on the entry plan
- cPanel, familiar to developers
- Phone and chat support
- Shorter 3-year commitment for the best price
- Lowest price on a 4-year prepay
- Backups and cheaper domain renewal
- Rated faster in published tests
- Only 3 sites on Premium
Which to pick
- One or two sites, lowest total cost: Hostinger Premium on a 4-year term.
- Several small sites, and you want cPanel: HostGator Baby or Business on a 3-year term.
- Lowest renewal of all: Namecheap at $55.88 a year.
- A store or busy site: Cloudways, with no renewal jump.
Also see HostGator pricing and Hostinger vs Bluehost.
Questions
Is Hostinger better than HostGator?
For one or two sites, usually yes: it costs less up front on a 4-year term and includes backups. HostGator is better if you want cPanel and more sites on the entry plan.
Which renews cheaper, HostGator or Hostinger?
Their entry plans both renew at about $10.99 a month. Hostinger's .com renewal is cheaper.
Does Hostinger use cPanel?
No. It uses its own hPanel. HostGator uses cPanel.
Do I have to prepay 4 years at Hostinger?
Only for the lowest price. Shorter terms cost more per month.
- Each host's published pricing and checkout totals as reported by price trackers (HostAdvice, Namechk, Checkthat, Bearhost, Themeisle, Webfin, Bloggingtitan), September–October 2026
- CNET HostGator review (Oct 1, 2026)
Based on published pricing, plan terms and specs, plus published reviews, noted above. Prices change often; check the cart before you buy.
Jean founded ShopHighSpeed after trying to find one straight answer about business internet in his own town. He has been a Comcast and Verizon Fios customer, and ranks providers on what they actually deliver, not on what they advertise.